Pellet Versus Filament Extrusion of Recycled Thermoplastics: A Controlled Comparative Study of Process Efficiency and Part Quality
Keywords:
Recycled Thermoplastics, Pellet Extrusion, Filament Extrusion, Process Efficiency, Mechanical PerformanceAbstract
This study quantitatively compared pellet and filament extrusion of recycled thermoplastics to determine differences in process efficiency, energy consumption, extrusion stability, physical part quality, and mechanical performance under controlled manufacturing conditions. A total of 60.00 kg of recycled thermoplastic was initially processed, of which 55.68 kg was retained after preparation, representing a 92.8% recovery rate. Twenty-four independent manufacturing runs were conducted, comprising 12 runs per extrusion route, and 274 analytically valid specimens were retained from 288 planned specimens, with overall data completeness of 99.2%. Direct pellet extrusion reduced total manufacturing time from 13.39 to 8.35 h, representing a 37.6% reduction, while increasing mass throughput from 0.391 to 0.684 kg/h, equivalent to approximately 74.9% higher throughput. Usable material yield increased from 89.7% to 94.8%, while specific energy consumption decreased from 2.04 to 1.31 kWh/kg of acceptable output. However, pellet extrusion exhibited greater material-flow variability at 6.84% compared with 3.92% for filament extrusion. Filament-extruded specimens consequently demonstrated better physical quality, with mean surface roughness decreasing from 18.74 to 13.28 µm, relative density increasing from 94.7% to 96.6%, and porosity decreasing from 5.31% to 3.47%. Tensile strength increased from 43.82 MPa for pellet specimens to 48.96 MPa for filament specimens, while interlayer bond strength increased from 27.63 to 31.74 MPa. Most principal route comparisons were statistically significant at p < 0.001 and demonstrated large effect sizes. Relative density was positively correlated with tensile strength (r = .71), whereas porosity was negatively correlated with tensile strength (r = −.69) and interlayer strength (r = −.72). Regression models explained 59–82% of adjusted variation across major outcomes, while sensitivity analyses altered principal effect estimates by less than 8%. The findings demonstrated a measurable efficiency–quality trade-off: direct pellet extrusion provided greater throughput, material utilization, and energy efficiency, whereas filament extrusion provided greater deposition stability, dimensional consistency, structural consolidation, and mechanical performance.


